‘Forbidden Broadway’ – A Hilarious Homage to Musical Theatre’s Best and Worst

Forbidden Broadway, the long-running satirical revue created by Gerard Alessandrini, has once again taken center stage, delivering its signature blend of sharp wit, musical parody, and affectionate ribbing of Broadway’s biggest hits. This latest iteration, titled Merrily We Stole A Song, features a talented cast comprising Chris Collins-Pisano, Katheryne Penny, Jenny Lee Stern, and Miles David Tillman, each bringing their unique flair to a show that both celebrates and skewers the world of musical theatre. As this hilarious parody brings Broadway to you on its North American Tour, Forbidden Broadway: Merrily We Stole a Song celebrates what makes theater great. Ready to explore what this show has to offer you? Continue on to find out more!
[Warning: Spoilers from Forbidden Broadway: Merrily We Stole A Song are below!]
Forbidden Broadway: A Satirical Symphony of Broadway’s Greatest Hits
From the moment the lights dim- or should I say flashlights turn on- Forbidden Broadway immerses the audience in a whirlwind tour of Broadway’s most iconic shows. The revue cleverly reimagines beloved numbers, infusing them with biting commentary and humorous twists that highlight the quirks and clichés of the originals. Whether it’s poking fun at the over-the-top dramatics of Les Misérables, the spectacle of The Phantom of the Opera, or the contemporary stylings of Hamilton, no show is safe from Forbidden Broadway‘s incisive lens.
Chris Collins-Pisano showcases remarkable versatility, effortlessly transforming into a myriad of characters with distinct voices and mannerisms. His portrayal of various Broadway archetypes is both exaggerated and endearing, capturing the essence of each role while amplifying their most humorous traits. Collins-Pisano’s comedic timing and expressive physicality make him a standout, eliciting laughter with every exaggerated gesture and satirical lyric.

Katheryne Penny brings a dynamic energy to the stage, her powerful vocals and sharp comedic instincts shining in every number. She masterfully balances the line between homage and satire, delivering performances that are both musically impressive and delightfully irreverent. Penny’s ability to mimic the vocal stylings of Broadway divas while injecting her own comedic twist adds depth to the parody, making her a vital component of the ensemble.
Jenny Lee Stern’s talent for impersonation is on full display as she channels the voices and personas of Broadway’s leading ladies with uncanny accuracy. Her renditions are not mere caricatures but nuanced performances that capture the idiosyncrasies of each character. Stern’s comedic prowess and vocal dexterity allow her to seamlessly transition between roles, keeping the audience engaged and entertained throughout the show.
Miles David Tillman infuses the production with a vibrant energy, his expressive performances and comedic timing adding a fresh dimension to the revue. Tillman’s versatility allows him to inhabit a range of characters, each brought to life with enthusiasm and a keen sense of satire. His contributions provide a rhythmic balance to the ensemble, ensuring that the show’s pacing remains lively and engaging.
A production that balances satire and celebration
Forbidden Broadway thrives on its ability to lampoon the very art form it celebrates, and this production strikes that balance with finesse. The direction ensures that each parody is delivered with clarity and purpose, while the musical arrangements support the comedic intent without overshadowing the performers. The minimalist set design and clever costume changes allow the cast’s talents to shine, keeping the focus on the performances and the humor inherent in the material.
Forbidden Broadway is a must-see for theatre enthusiasts
This rendition of Forbidden Broadway is a testament to the enduring appeal of theatrical satire. With a talented cast that brings both reverence and ridicule to Broadway’s most cherished productions, the show offers a delightful experience for theatre aficionados and casual fans alike. It’s a reminder that while the world of musical theatre can be grandiose and melodramatic, it’s also ripe for affectionate mockery—a balance that Forbidden Broadway achieves with aplomb.
Forbidden Broadway: Merrily We Stole A Song is currently on its North American tour! Want to know more about this show before it arrives in a city near you? Check out Forbidden Broadway’s website about the show’s history and what you can expect from this production! Have you seen Forbidden Broadway before? Plan on checking out this tour? Let us know on social media @boxseatbabes!
Forbidden Broadway: Merrily We Stole a Song | The Box Seat Babes Podcast