‘Mayfair Witches: Season 2’ A Season Trying to Prove It Knows What It Is
Season 2 of Anne Rice’s Mayfair Witches arrives with something to prove. Season 1 left many viewers intrigued but unconvinced—heavy on atmosphere, light on coherence. This second chapter doesn’t abandon those flaws so much as attempt to outrun them. What results is a season that’s more confident in tone and scale, yet still frustratingly unsure of what kind of show it wants to be: prestige gothic drama, supernatural soap, or franchise connective tissue. I wanted this season to settle in, to deepen rather than sprawl. Sometimes it does. Often, it doesn’t.
[Warning: spoilers from Mayfair Witches: Season 2 are below!]
The consequences of Rowan’s actions arrive in Anne Rice’s Mayfair Witches season 2
Alexandra Daddario remains the show’s most reliable anchor. Her Rowan Fielding is perpetually on the edge—of rage, of grief, of revelation—and while the writing often forces her into repetitive emotional beats, Daddario sells the internal chaos. Rowan’s struggle this season isn’t just about power; it’s about consequence. She created something she cannot control, and the show is at its strongest when it lets that guilt breathe.
That said, Rowan is written in circles. The season frequently mistakes intensity for development, and there are moments where you can feel the character stalling because the plot needs her to hesitate one more episode.
Lasher, now fully embodied, should be the season’s most disturbing element. Conceptually, he’s fascinating: part demon, part child, part reflection of Rowan’s suppressed desires. In practice, he’s unevenly handled. At times, he’s chilling—an uncanny presence that destabilizes every scene. At others, he feels oddly underwritten, a narrative device rather than a fully realized threat.
The show wants Lasher to represent temptation, legacy, and corruption all at once, but it rarely slows down enough to explore any of those ideas in depth. He’s haunting, yes—but often more in theory than impact.
The Mayfair Family: A Name Without a Center
For a series ostensibly about a cursed family, Mayfair Witches still struggles to make the Mayfairs feel like more than background noise. Season 2 introduces more faces, more betrayals, more secrets—but very little emotional architecture holding them together. Characters drift in and out with alarming speed, and relationships are asserted rather than earned.
Harry Hamlin’s Cortland remains entertainingly monstrous, but even he feels like a holdover from a different, more lurid version of the show. There’s a soapiness here that could be delicious if the writing embraced it. Instead, the series half-commits, leaving many family dynamics feeling oddly hollow.
This is where Season 2 most clearly stumbles. The show throws everything at the screen—rituals, prophecies, Talamasca intrigue, moral debates—without giving viewers enough grounding. Episodes often feel like they’re racing toward revelations that haven’t been properly set up.
There are strong individual scenes, even strong episodes, but they rarely cohere into a satisfying arc. Instead of escalation, the season relies on accumulation, and by the end, the weight of unresolved threads becomes more exhausting than intriguing.
Atmosphere: Still the Show’s Strongest Spell
If Mayfair Witches excels at anything, it’s mood. The visual language this season is richer and more assured: candlelit interiors, decaying grandeur, ritualistic imagery that leans into gothic excess without apology. When the show stops explaining itself and lets the environment speak, it’s genuinely compelling.
These moments hint at the series it could be—one where dread is earned through silence, stillness, and suggestion rather than exposition dumps.
Season 2’s connections to AMC’s larger Anne Rice universe are both exciting and distracting. On paper, the crossover potential is thrilling. On screen, it often feels like a reminder that Mayfair Witches is being asked to serve something bigger than itself before it has fully figured out its own identity.
Instead of deepening its core mythology, the show occasionally feels like it’s auditioning—proof-of-concept television rather than fully confident storytelling.
Final Thoughts on Anne Rice’s Mayfair Witches: A Better Season, Still an Unsettled One
Season 2 is undeniably an improvement over Season 1. It’s darker, more intentional, and occasionally genuinely gripping. But improvement doesn’t equal fulfillment. The show still struggles with focus, character cohesion, and narrative restraint.
I don’t dislike Mayfair Witches. I’m frustrated by it. The ingredients are here—strong performances, evocative visuals, a rich source of mythology—but the execution remains scattered. Season 2 casts a more confident spell than before, yet it still dissipates before fully taking hold.
For fans of gothic television, it’s worth watching. For skeptics, it may confirm the same suspicion: that this series knows how to look powerful, but hasn’t yet learned how to be powerful.
Mayfair Witches: Season 2 is streaming on AMC+ and available on Netflix in the U.S. Have you watched this series before? What did you think of the most recent season? Let us know what you’re most excited for from the Immortal Universe on AMC? Let us know on social media @BoxSeatBabes!
Exclusive Interview: Katherine Mutschler of University of Detroit Mercy’s Witch
