From Grinch to Grateful in Meadow Brook Theatre’s ‘A Christmas Carol’
For as long as I can remember, Meadow Brooke Theatre’s production of A Christmas Carol has been a beloved December tradition in my family. From a young age, my grandmother, mother, and I always dressed up for a night at the theater, often grabbing a bite to eat at Buddy’s across the street before braving the snow to climb the stairs to the theater’s entrance. The moment you step inside, it’s like being transported straight into the pages of Charles Dickens’ novel—beautiful Christmas decorations line the halls, and the air is filled with the sweet sounds of carolers singing all the festive classics we love. While many theaters put on holiday shows, it’s these special touches that truly set Meadow Brook apart. People don’t just come for the performance; they come for the entire experience and the chance to create lasting memories.
Directed by Cheryl L. Marshall & Travis W. Walter, this production brings a mix of emotional depth and festive cheer while capturing the essence of Dickens’ novel and infusing it with fresh vibrancy and a rich ensemble of performances. From the chilling visits of the ghosts to the heartwarming redemption of Ebenezer Scrooge, this rendition delivers a satisfying balance of humor, drama, and the true spirit of Christmas.
[Warning: spoilers from A Christmas Carol]
A masterful performance by Phil Powers as Ebenezer Scrooge
At the heart of any production of A Christmas Carol is the character of Ebenezer Scrooge, and in this production, Phil Powers’ portrayal of the miserly, cold-hearted businessman is nothing short of exceptional. Powers brings depth and complexity to Scrooge, which allows the character to evolve throughout the play in a way that feels both believable and heartfelt. Early in the show, Powers embodies the embodiment of greed and selfishness, delivering his lines with a sharpness and rigidity that clearly establishes Scrooge as someone who has long ago forsaken the joy of life.
However, Powers’ performance stands out because of the authenticity with which he portrays Scrooge’s transformation. The turning point comes during his encounters with the three ghosts, and Powers handles each of these moments with emotional range. Whether reacting to the haunting revelations of the Ghost of Christmas Past or wrestling with the terrifying visions shown to him by the Ghost of Christmas Future, Powers captures the internal struggle of a man coming face-to-face with his past mistakes. His transition from a hardened, bitter miser to a joyful, redeemed soul is a journey that feels both earned and deeply moving.
A strong supporting cast brings Dickens’ characters to life
The supporting cast in this production of A Christmas Carol is nothing short of impressive, with each actor bringing their own special touch to the iconic characters that populate the world of Dickens’ London. Stephen Blackwell shines as Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s loyal but overworked employee. Blackwell brings a quiet dignity to the role, portraying Cratchit as a man who, despite his hardships, still possesses a deep love for his family. His interactions with his children, particularly with Tiny Tim (played by Russell Clauser/Robert Spiro), are among the most tender and poignant moments of the show. The portrayal of Bob Cratchit is especially moving when contrasted with Scrooge’s initial disregard for his employee’s well-being.
Antonio Vettraino’s Fred, Scrooge’s cheerful and hopeful nephew, provides a welcome contrast to Scrooge’s grim outlook. Vettraino’s Fred is warm, optimistic, and relentlessly kind-hearted, even in the face of Scrooge’s scorn. His persistent invitations to Christmas dinner and infectious good cheer highlight the importance of familial bonds and love, no matter how distant the relationship might seem. Vettraino’s portrayal is particularly effective in conveying the youthful optimism that Scrooge once had, reminding the audience that even a man as cold as Scrooge was once capable of joy.
Chip Duford’s dual roles as Fezziwig is a standout. As Fezziwig, Duford radiates warmth and generosity, playing the role of Scrooge’s former employer with an exuberance and liveliness that perfectly captures the festive spirit of the character. The Fezziwig ball scene is a high point of the show, with Duford’s energy drawing the audience into a world of joy and celebration.
The Spirits: a fantastical and memorable ensemble in A Christmas Carol
The role of the three ghosts—each representing a different facet of Scrooge’s journey—is critical to the play’s success, and the actors playing these spirits do not disappoint. Mary Magyari, as the Spirit of Christmas Past, gives a gentle and ethereal performance. Her graceful movements and serene presence evoke a sense of nostalgia and longing, transporting both Scrooge and the audience to his lost childhood and earlier years. Magyari’s tender portrayal brings warmth and reflection to the character, allowing Scrooge’s past to unfold in a bittersweet and redemptive way.
David Aron Damane’s portrayal of the Spirit of Christmas Present is vibrant and full of life. His exuberance is matched by a wise and almost omniscient air that suggests the spirit knows the true nature of the people he visits. Damane’s performance is particularly effective in his interactions with the Cratchit family, where his joyful demeanor starkly contrasts the hardships they face. His infectious laughter and boisterous mannerisms serve as a reminder of the importance of enjoying the present moment, even in times of struggle.
As the Ghost of Christmas Future, Sean Ryan delivers a chilling and unsettling performance. Without uttering a word, Ryan’s presence fills the stage with an ominous sense of foreboding. The Spirit’s silent gestures and unwavering gaze leave a lasting impact, reinforcing the gravity of Scrooge’s choices and the consequences they could have on his future. Ryan’s performance adds a sense of terror to the production, making the Ghost of Christmas Future a truly memorable and spine-chilling character.
The Ensemble: adding richness and depth to the story
The ensemble cast in A Christmas Carol brings Dickens’ world to life with their varied performances as merchants, Londoners, and everyday people. Anthony Guest, Jacob Lipski, David Schoen, and Sam Vankampen bring to life the bustling streets of Victorian London with their spirited performances. Each actor adds a layer of authenticity to the setting, making the world feel rich with life.
Tobin Hissong’s portrayal of Old Joe, the shady undertaker, brings an added layer of comic relief. At the same time, Raeghan Cantrelle, as the Charwoman, and Stephanie Nichols, as the Laundress, showcase the play’s more colorful characters with humor and flair. The children in the ensemble—particularly Oliver Caloia/Wyatt Reynolds as the Turkey Boy—bring innocence and charm to the performance, brightening the stage with their youthful energy.
Final thoughts on Meadow Brook Theatre’s A Christmas Carol
While not every individual may be named, this production boasts a wealth of talent and a team of dedicated professionals who bring the story to life both onstage and offstage. The behind-the-scenes work is just as impressive, from set and lighting design to sound and choral arrangements. As someone who has taken on these roles before, I want to give a special shout-out to the hardworking crew. Every production requires a village, and the dedication and passion of the Meadow Brook team are on full display here. Well done to everyone involved!
Meadow Brook Theatre’s A Christmas Carol is running now through December 22nd. Don’t miss out on this seasonal experience, which is excellent for all ages! Let us know your thoughts on A Christmas Carol on social media @mycosmiccircus or @boxseatbabes and now @CosmicCircusBroadway.com on Bluesky!
Exclusive Interview: Phil Powers, Scrooge in A Christmas Carol
